Featured Stories

Categories

The Real Cost of Downtime in Manufacturing

Graham Immerman
May 08, 2018

For most manufacturers, downtime is the single largest source of lost production time. As you probably already know, Downtime is any period of time when a machine is not in production (quite literally, down). Downtime can be categorized to help identify patterns in machine performance. It receives a high level of attention since equipment failures and breakdowns are highly visible. However, as visible as downtime often is, most companies significantly underestimate their true downtime, and over 80% of companies are unable to calculate their true downtime costs correctly (“What is the True Downtime Cost (TDC)?” 2017).

To that end, not all downtime is created equal; in reality the greatest expense is caused by unplanned downtime. Unplanned downtime is downtime that occurs unexpectedly or as a result of a failure (for example, a hardware failure or waiting on appropriate materials to complete a task). Common categories of unplanned downtime include excessive tool changeover, excessive job changeover, lack of operator, and unplanned machine maintenance.

Impact Image 9

(MachineMetrics notifies operators to add human context to machine downtime via tablets)

When unplanned downtime occurs, no value is being produced but the cost of overhead operations continues to grow, which directly impacts a company's bottom line. According to Analyst firm Aberdeen Research82 percent of companies have experienced unplanned downtime over the past three years and that unplanned downtime can cost a company as much as $260,000 an hour!

A new study sponsored by ServiceMax (conducted by Vanson Bourne of GE Digital), “After The Fall: Cost, Causes and Consequences of Unplanned Downtime,” surveyed 450 field service and IT decision makers across the Globe and in many industries including, manufacturing, medical, oil and gas, energy and utilities, and transportation. The study found that productivity, IT, and customer service are still hit hardest by unplanned downtime, and that the reverberation is felt across businesses as a whole.

The same study also found that unplanned downtime is also driving renewed investment in digital transformation:

  • Of the 82 percent of companies that have experienced unplanned downtime over the past three years, those outages lasted an average of four hours and cost an average of $2 million.
  • Unplanned downtime results in loss of customer trust and productivity — 46 percent couldn’t deliver services to customers, 37 percent lost production time on a critical asset, and 29 percent were totally unable to service or support specific equipment or assets.
  • Only 12 percent of respondents from organizations in the US consider their organization to be exactly where they need to be and ahead of their competitors in terms of their digital industrial journey — compared to 16 percent in both the UK and France, and 23 percent in Germany.

(Customizable downtime reasons allow users to track planned and unplanned downtimes)

Another startling statistic is that more than 70 percent of respondents aren’t fully aware of when their equipment is due for maintenance, upgrade or replacement. Even with the knowledge that unplanned downtime is so costly, manufacturers’ most frequently used approaches to maintenance—which should ideally help reduce unplanned downtime—are not necessarily effective in reducing it. A recent GE Study found that than only 24% of operators describe their maintenance approach as a "predictive" one based on data and analytics. The rest either took a reactive or time-based approach. (Figure 3) In terms of the unplanned downtime associated with each approach, reactive approaches averaged 8.43% annually, with 7.96% for planned, and 5.42% for data/monitoring approaches.

Thus, the unplanned downtime Pareto is difficult to produce. It requires understanding all downtime that occurs on a machine, and not just the ones that we can gather through the machine's PLC/Control. Traditionally, obtaining the necessary data involves log sheets that require the operator to manually log all significant downtime. This manual approach will likely miss frequent downtime events that are only a few minutes each, but add up to a significant amount of time. Typically the actual data is logged well after the incident occurs, so the time is not very accurate. Utilizing a platform that tracks the cycle status of a machine in real-time is necessary to generate data for a downtime Pareto. It's also necessary for the operator to categorize each downtime event into reasonable buckets during or shortly after an event.

Impact Image 6

(Downtime reports are visible by machine, job, shift, or operator for comparative analysis)

Of course, while gathering data is a key driver to solving problems and having a better understanding of downtime, just obtaining more data does not mean that an organization will know what to do with it. According to a recent study by Accenture, 60% of operators cite dealing with outcomes of data gathered as a major challenge. It is important to understand the reasons for collecting increasing amounts of data and how the data can be applied to improve condition-based monitoring and predictive maintenance, including:

  • The ability to identify data-based patterns
  • Cognitive learning capabilities
  • Opportunities to leverage data in the Cloud for crossorganization/industry comparisons
  • The ability to share data with trusted service providers for additional analysis and insights

There is a significant opportunity to continuing carving down unplanned downtime through digitization, but as Deloitte notes in a recent report, “Simply ‘doing’ digital things will not make an organization digital.” Organizations need to go beyond just technology changes to truly embrace the benefits of digitization

To accomplish this, MachineMetrics has risen to the challenge of helping companies hone in on those problem areas that might otherwise be elusive to many. The platform uniquely allows an organization to aggregate both machine data (from any type of machine, legacy or modern) and human data to accurately attribute and categorize downtime to specific, top reasons for downtime, both planned and unplanned. 

All of these various reasons are visualized to your team in a way that makes understanding your top reasons for downtime and the action that needs to be taken as simple as possible. For example, MachineMetrics can measure how long it takes to changeover jobs. If the downtime Pareto shows that changeovers are your biggest source of downtime, a team can focus their efforts on reducing the time it takes to perform one. Take it a step further and use the downtime data to look at which changeovers are the biggest pains, and then potentially plan longer production runs of a certain product to minimize the number of changeovers to that product type. 

ImpactImage1

(MachineMetrics aggregates all downtime events and visualizes top reasons for easy and immediate action)

Because MachineMetrics aggregates any alarm, fault, or maintenance alert that comes through in the data, the information we are capturing has numerous use cases that become quite applicable in a company's efforts to significantly reduce downtime. Here's a few:
  • Analyzing and diagnosing alerts so action can be taken at the right time, predicting and preventing future downtime due to maintenance scheduling
  • Reducing unscheduled downtime due to product failures and irregular operating conditions
  • Understanding equipment utilization rates
  • Evaluating the frequency and duration of alarms and running analytics to help understand common problems that need attention, combining that effort with notifications to predictively alert maintenance technicians and machine operators to more severe problems
  • Monitor any machine condition such as status, loads, temperature, operator overrides, controller mode, speeds, feeds, etc in real-time and as a time series graph to determine when thresholds are exceeded.
  • Creating PM schedules based on calendar time or usage time.
  • Creating Tool life management schedules based on tool usage or in-cut time so you can notify your team when a tool needs to be changed.

If unplanned downtime based on machine breakages is causing unplanned downtime, MachineMetrics can manage your implementation of a Preventative Maintenance Program. Using data and our sophisticated machine learning algorithms, you can begin to predict when certain parts will fail and replace them before they ever occur. Machines alarms can be a precondition to significant failures. Detailed analytics can help understand common problems that need attention. MachineMetrics will automatically classify the severity of alarms based on the amount of downtime that the alarm typically causes. Combined with alerts, this is a powerful capability that can predictively alert maintenance technicians and machine operators to severe problems. If the data shows that multiple parts of a machine will likely fail within weeks of each other and it takes hours of disassembly to gain access to that machine element you can save time by replacing them all at once instead.

The first step to solving any problem is defining the problem. For downtime, knowing when, where, and how downtime occurs is essential to knowing how to prevent it. An early step toward reducing unexpected production backups or outright downtime can be achieved by carefully and accurately tracking when and where downtime occurs. With MachineMetrics, we've made tracking that process as easy and user friendly as possible so you can get to the bottom of your downtime issues and have a better understanding of how to improve your process. The time is now to invest in the digital tools that will transform your business and the technology to drive continuous improvements into the next generation of manufacturing.

Contact us and start reducing your downtime today!

 

Comments

Related posts

The Time is Now for the Smart Factory
17Jun

The Time is Now for the Smart Factory

Almost everyone has become accustomed to smart phones, smart televisions, and even the concept of smart cars.  And technology has advanced far enough that people understand generally what expectations...

Industry 4.0- You Can Get There from Here
12Jun

Industry 4.0- You Can Get There from Here

There is an old New England expression that states, “You can’t get there from here”.  It originated as a way of explaining the path to a destination that can’t be accessed without extensive, complex a...

Why should you care about Industry 4.0?
07Jun

Why should you care about Industry 4.0?

  As Industry 4.0 surges forward, many manufacturers are still pondering what it means and how or whether the latest industrial revolution will affect them.  First coined in Germany over ten years ago...

Industrial IoT Creates a New Value Stream for OEMs
23May

Industrial IoT Creates a New Value Stream for OEMs

  An issue in manufacturing that is singular to OEM is the speed with which they can respond with service to the machines, in the case of a failure. In the past, this has usually meant an actual failu...

Reassessing the MES Mess
08May

Reassessing the MES Mess

David Westrom Dave Westrom is VP of Business Development at MachineMetrics. Dave has spent much of his career in executive team roles at innovative IIoT companies. He has led business development orga...

Exploring The 6 Core Pillars of Industry 4.0
03May

Exploring The 6 Core Pillars of Industry 4.0

 Innovation, in manufacturing in particular, has exploded, thanks to Industry 4.0. The term was coined to reflect the trend towards the use of technology, automation, and data acquisition in manufactu...

INDUSTRIAL IOT AND THE MOVE FROM PREVENTIVE TO PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE
24Apr

INDUSTRIAL IOT AND THE MOVE FROM PREVENTIVE TO PREDICTIVE MAINTENANCE

One of the most important trends in the last few decades has been the movement toward lean manufacturing.  As companies began to review and change their operating procedures to eliminate waste, effici...

What is Industry 4.0?
17Apr

What is Industry 4.0?

  Known as the fourth industrial revolution since the 18th century, Industry 4.0 is an all-encompassing term to refer to the way computers, data and automation are evolving and coming together to chan...

Sensor Data vs PLC Data: Why Getting Deep Data Is the Right Way to Go!
09Apr

Sensor Data vs PLC Data: Why Getting Deep Data Is the Right Way to Go!

  When it comes to collecting data with industrial IoT within the world of manufacturing, it isn’t just about quantity. It’s also about the quality of the information that you are gathering from vario...

5 Myths- Manufacturing During Industry 4.0
02Apr

5 Myths- Manufacturing During Industry 4.0

The fourth industrial revolution is upon us, and as you may know, this means change. As an industry, it is imperative that manufacturers adopt new technologies and increased connectivity that will ena...